You are viewing ivanolix

 
 
16 December 2009 @ 09:32 pm
Beginning vidding tutorial (Mac users) - for frolicndetour  
Start Vidding on a Mac - A tutorial for computer Luddites - ;-)

Disclaimer: I’ve only been vidding a grand total of four months and am not a computer expert myself. Hence, this is an intuitive viewpoint gained from trial and error. Also, though everything is explained in detail for the sake of thoroughness, it may be a little overkill for some. I’m not trying to insult your intelligence, truly!

Before you start: Find as many vids as possible that you enjoyed watching and watch them again to get a feel of how they’re put together. Also keep an eye on the pacing, scene transitions and any effects that are non-pacing related. Do this with many vids by many different vidders to get the best results. And realize that whatever cool tricks they may have added? You probably won’t be able to do with iMovie. If you still want to make a vid (and personally, my favorite vids are the ones that have good pacing and almost no effects), keep on reading.

Next, you should have obtained these things:

*A Mac computer running Leopard (10.5) or Snow Leopard (10.6)
*Quicktime X, Quicktime Pro, or any basic video editor software
*iMovie 6 HD
*AVI, WMV, or MOV files of the episodes/movie you plan on vidding
*25+ Gb extra space on your hard drive

Now, the tutorial itself:

Part 1 - The Tools

Step 1: iMovie 6 HD Overview


When you open the application, hit “Create New Project” and select your video format. Use DV Widescreen to get the best results; DV is doable, but creates square letter-boxed vids. Once your file is named and saved in a folder, look at your program. There are five buttons on the right side that change what you view in the sidebar, and three tracks for clips/audio on the bottom of the screen. The first thing you need to do is import your song (choose “Import” in the File menu, or use the keyboard shortcut Shift-Command-I). If the song is in iTunes, you follow the pathway of Music > iTunes > iTunes Music > Artist > Song to import. This should take about a minute to import, and the song should then go in the second track at the bottom of the screen. (If your song needs editing of some kind, this should be done previously, as iMovie can only clip a song roughly.)

Next, you need your video.

Step 2: Getting your video into iMovie

All video files will be imported into iMovie as DV files for editing, no matter what format they originally came from. DV files take about 4 times as long to load as the actual length of the clip; therefore a one minute clip takes about 4 minutes to load. Yes, this is forever. It helps to have all your video clips for the vid in a folder before you start importing; then, you can import the folder, and as it may take a couple hours you can do something else in the meantime.

So, with that in mind, you will need to extract the specific clips you want from the episodes to avoid having to import the entire episode (a nightmare of a wait!). To do this, open your full episode files in your video editor. (If you have the latest Mac upgrade, this is really simple in the program Quicktime X. You select the “Trim” (Command-T) option from the “Edit” menu, and then move the little wipers on the bottom of the file to select which part of the file you want to select. Once you have a rough cut of the scene, click “Trim”, and then DO NOT SAVE. Choose “Save As” in the “File” menu to keep your clip AND the episode it came from.) After you have saved a whole bunch of scenes to use for your vid, import them into iMovie (and as I said before, it’s easier to import a whole folder of clips than one at a time). Since the clips are imported into DV format, they become very large in filesize, which is why you need around 25 Gb of free hard drive space to vid. Once the vid is done, though, you can export it to a normal file size.

Once imported, your clips will appear in the right sidebar of the main iMovie window under the sub-heading “Clips”. From there, you can click and drag them to the video track on the bottom of the window. Make sure that the tip of the cursor is centered on the video track when dragging, otherwise the video just bounces back to the “Clips” sidebar. Anything in the video track can also be dragged back to the “Clips” sidebar. Likewise, anything that ends up in the Trash bucket (lowest right corner of the main window) can be dragged to either the video track or the “Clips” sidebar.

Troubleshooting note:
If your computer has limited memory, it may freeze the program while importing a large file or many smaller files. This only happens as soon as the file is finished, though, so if you “Force Quit” iMovie and restart, you will not need to reimport the clip. However, since the program had not processed it, the imported clip will be in the Trash until you drag it to the “Clips” sidebar. Usually the program will prompt you to look in the Trash after a freezing incident.

Important term to know: The line that shows where you are playing or paused in your vid is called the “playhead”. It shows the timestamp in terms of minutes, seconds, and frames (more about that in a second).

Next, let’s get familiar with your options in this application.

Step 3: What you can do in iMovie


Sadly, iMovie was not designed for fanvidding, and so your options are very limited. This is not necessarily a bad thing, unless you like fancy tricks in your vids. However, given how few options there are, it’s not hard to get to know them. Let’s get to know your essentials:

Split Video Clip at Playhead (Command-T)


From the “Edit” menu. This is almost the only tool you need in iMovie. Once your scenes are in the video track, all you have to do is trim them to the right length, depending on the rhythm of your vid and song. Note that the default visual size of the clip on the video track is relative to how long all the clips/songs you have in the vid timeline; the default is to show all clips onscreen. When editing, you may need to drag the slider in the lower left corner of the screen to zoom in on a certain clip or clips, especially if you are only trimming a few frames. Which leads us to frames.

There are 30 frames per second in each video file, and often smooth editing comes down to a matter of 2 or 3 of those frames. It is not usually difficult to trim a clip within 5 frames, but anything smaller and you may have trouble. Make sure that the clip is properly zoomed in upon on the timeline (using the lower-left-corner slider), and if you have to, use your spacebar key to pause/unpause clips as fast as you can until you move the playhead along the couple frames you need. Once the clip is trimmed, you can either delete the unneeded footage, or drag it to the “Clips” sidebar if you think you might need it later in the vid. Anything deleted may be recovered unless you empty the Trash. Next feature:

Show Clip Volume Levels


Another essential, found in the “View” menu. All your video files will be imported at full volume, which is probably quieter than the song you chose, but not quiet enough. At some time in the vidding process, you will need to make all the clips silent by choosing this tool. The audio level will appear as a purple line that you can drag up and down. Click at the beginning of each clip to make a smooth change, and once the volume is changed, choose the same option from the “View” menu to hide the purple line so that you can edit the clips themselves more freely.

Next, let’s look at some editing essentials in the right sidebar. To view all your editing options, click on the “Editing” button just over from the “Clips” button. There will be another set of buttons at the top, default to “Titles”.

Titles

This simply means any credits. The options are not very expansive, but they are functional. You simply choose what kind of title (you can preview everything), type what you want into the text boxes, change the font/color/size if you want to, and finally adjust the speed. Once your title is ready, you move the playhead to wherever you want to put your credits and click “Add”. The default option is for the title to be a separate scene, but if you uncheck the checkbox that says “Over black”, the title will play over a scene in the video like post-theme-song credits in most TV shows. The next button at the top is “Transitions”.

Transitions


These are exactly what they sound like. You can preview each option at various speeds (measured in frames) to see what they do to your scene transitions. One note, the length is somewhat limited. You can do a 2 or 5 frame transition, but not a 3 frame one (no matter how delicate you are with moving the length slider). Once you have assembled the transition you want, simply click and drag it down to the video track. After it is placed, if you click on it you may adjust the settings while the transition is still in place, and then click “Update” to enact your changes. The next button at the top is “Video FX”

Video FX


These options change the look of your clips. Most of the options are fairly cheesy and intense, but if you play around with the levels, you can create some pretty effects with most of them. Unlike titles or transitions, these affect the entire clip you have selected in the video track.

The most important option you should know about is:

Fast/Slow/Reverse


Unlike the other options under “Video FX”, this is useful for while you are trimming clips. If your clip is a little too short, you can adjust the speed with the slider. Be careful—the tiniest movement of the slider can produce visible changes to the clip appearance and length. You will usually only need to move it a tiny bit left or right, and even then, you may need to re-trim your clip once lengthened/shortened. The “Reverse” option should be self explanatory.

The other button on the top is “Audio FX”, but most vids will not need this.

Important note about “Video FX”: By applying one of the effects to a clip, you are essentially adding a “filter” over the clip. If you wish to delete the effect, you click on the clip and hit “delete”. The effect will be deleted and the clip will stay. This is true if you want to delete a clip as well, though. If after editing a clip you wish to trim it or delete it fully, you will have to hit the “delete” button at least two times to delete both the effect and the clip itself. This can occasionally be a pain.

Step 4: Using the Tools to Vid and What Happens Next

Once you have trimmed, affected, silenced, and completely prepared your clips, you need to arrange them. The song (and any other sounds you might have imported as sound effects) can be dragged around the vid, and the clips can be dragged around in relation to the song. At any point, you can hit play and see/hear the vid you have created so far. Remember to save often!!!

Once your vid is completed, it is still in an view-and-edit format, so you need to export it into a view-only format. Go to the “File” menu and hit “Export”. The simplest option is to export it as a Quicktime video, which is the default setting. Use the “Full Quality” option if you want it to be full sized, but this will be a very large video in both pixels and filesize. If you click the “Expert Settings” option, you will be prompted with another window. On this window, click “Options”. On the next window, click “Settings” in the “Video” subheading. Here you can adjust the quality of the video; “High” is the setting I normally use, and it creates vids that are usually less than 100 Mb. Once this sends you back to the previous window, click the “Size” option in the “Video” subheading. You can letterbox your video here by choosing any of the preset options, or you can create your own size with the “Custom” option. It involves a little basic math, but you can calculate proportions fairly easily to end up with a proper widescreen vid. My favorite size is 652 x 360.

Once you have your options ready, and your file name chosen, simply click “Share”. It will take around 8 - 12 minutes for your video to export. If you chose the “Full Quality” settings and the resulting DV file appears too large, you may either re-export the video, or open the video in Quicktime and choose “Save As” to transform it into a smaller MOV file (~50 Mb or so).

Now...hopefully that’s all the technical details you need to know for now. If you're completely new to vidding in general, not just Mac programs, below is something to give you an idea of how to think about creating vids.


Part 2 - The Art

Remember what I said in the beginning about watching vids you liked for inspiration? If you have a specific video that you want to make, try to look for videos in the same kind of genre—similar tempo, story style, etc. It helps to get an idea of how to put a video together. If you already have an idea about those things, here are the steps you can follow next:

Step 1: Absorbing Your Song

Listen to the song you want to vid. Listen to it several times before you open up iMovie. Once you have the vidbunny firmly in your head, listen to the song and envision the basic structure of your vid (if you’re familiar enough with the source material for this to work). Listen to it again with the same idea in mind. Think about what clips you’ll probably need, and listen to the song again for the rhythm.

There are three obvious ways to vid to rhythm. One is to vid to the rhythm of the lyrics. Not every line is sung with the same emphasis, and you may want to hold certain shots longer on held words or pauses, and you may want to speed up the shots if the singer has a point in the song where they sing fast. Two is to vid to the music, the speed of the background harmony and beat, which will probably have a consistent rhythm (but not an even one, usually). Three is to vid to the actual beat. Nearly all songs you will want to vid have a beat that is measured in 4 counts. This count may be fast or slow depending on the song, but it’s an underlying format like a heartbeat, and it’s a little easier to vid to than the other rhythm options because it’s steady throughout the song. You can vid every 4 beats, every 2 beats, every beat, whatever. It depends on how fast the count is. You don’t have to choose just one; it depends what feels right as you’re vidding, and what looks right. Consistency is good, but you don’t need to follow it rigidly.

Step 2: Storyboarding


Next, you will need to storyboard. Hopefully you’re vidding because you have both an ear and an eye for video as a medium—it’ll make this step come naturally. Go find the lyrics to the song you’re using, and put it in a word processor. If you’ve listened to your song enough times, you should have a feel for whichever rhythm you’ll be vidding to, so you should know how often you’ll need to change clips among the lyrics. If you have a story for your vid beyond just the lyrics, write out in a paragraph or two how your vid is going to go. Example: “Verse 1, ______; chorus 1, ______; verse 2, _______” etc.

For the more specific storyboarding, one way you can visualize your vid is like this: Divide the lyrics into sections of words, and add in something like “(instrumental)” for any place in the song where there aren’t words, but you’ll obviously need a shot there anyways. At each line break, you mark down a short description of what clip you’d like to use. Some specific clips should come automatically to mind; others, you might go “I need Character X doing something with Y”, and so you’ll need to track down an example. Either way, you start plotting down these points. Once you know all (or most) of the clips you’ll need, you have to go get them.

Step 3: Gathering Clips

Hopefully you’ll know most of the clips you’ll need to use through listening to the song over and over, and brainstorming. If so, this will mostly be bookwork. What I do to make it simple is gather all the short descriptions (from the storyboard) of the scenes I’m going to use and then put them into chronological order. Then I go through the episodes and pull each scene, name it according to the episode (and a number if there’s more than one per episode) and then put them in a folder. If you know all the clips you need, this may only take 2-3 hours. If you don’t, or you aren’t sure where the clips you want are, this process can take half a day or more. But believe me, it’s worth having all the clips ready at hand before you start vidding. It’s also worth it to wait however long it takes to import all the clips before you start editing. Once you get into the groove, it’s frustrating to have to stop and wait ten minutes to upload a new clip. Just like when cooking, you want all your ingredients at hand before you put the pan on the heat. So, after you have your clips in your program, then what?


Step 4: Assembling Your Vid

Three words are essential to vidding: pacing, pacing, pacing. If your clips are timed slightly off, or they last too long, or they don’t follow a good rhythm, it doesn’t matter how magnificent your vidding vision is: viewers won’t care. This is all subjective, so all I have to offer are a few guidelines that I use:

*Try not to let a clip last any longer than you have to without a change in angle ("have to" could mean for dramatic effect or if you have a slow song). I aim for less than three seconds, because I like crisp vids. Meaning, a clip can be from a single scene and be longer than 3 seconds, but if the camera angle changes halfway through, it’s really more like two 2-second clips. Why this guideline? One, most songs have a quick rhythm, and long shots drag them down. Two, your viewers have already seen the full scenes that all your clips are from, so they don’t usually need to see the whole thing again to get whatever point you’re making. Some vids call for languid speed, but most work better with upbeat pacing.

*Whenever possible, try to use shots where the characters are doing something. The clip may not be long, but if the character is standing still and being filmed with a steadi-cam, it’ll feel twice as long as it actually is. If the camera is moving, or the character is moving (even as simple as turning their head), or better yet if there’s actual action going on...the pacing will feel much faster, and faster is usually better. (BSG is a great fandom for vidding, since even “talky” shots are filmed hand-held and are therefore always moving a little. Stargate, on the other hand, is a pain to vid with all sorts of briefing room/science lab banter scenes filmed with static cameras.)

*Don’t forget transitions. They don’t need to be obvious, and in fact too many obvious transitions and the viewer will probably get lost in the special effects, but unless you want your vid to be “snappy”, you need something between shots. Using the transition “Cross Dissolve” at a speed of 2 frames is almost invisible to the naked eye, but it smooths out normal transitions very well. “Fade In” or “Wash In” (and “Fade Out” and “Wash Out”) can be used for emphasis, or the beginnings and ends of vids, or even between sections of the same vid.

Beyond that...everything is intuition. Some people vid out of order, some (like me) vid from beginning to end. However you choose to assemble your vid is up to you. Whatever you do, “Save” often!!! And make sure to continually go back and watch the stuff you’ve already vidded to make sure that your pacing stays consistent as you vid. And on that note, the last step:

Step 5: Polishing Your Vid


Let your vid sit. And sit, and sit some more. Inevitably, some of your scene choices will haunt you, and you’ll be itching to go back and edit them. Same with pacing; there’ll be that one transition that’s just a couple frames too fast, and it’ll bug you forever if you’ve already posted the vid by then. While your vid is sitting, make sure you watch it frequently. Watch it to get the feel of the whole vid, watch it for the little things, watch it to make sure your changes were an improvement. Give it plenty of time. And having a beta is always a good idea as well, or at least someone to watch it and give you a general thumbs up or down.

One important note
: If you realize that one of your scenes was cut too short, and you need a couple extra frames on it to make the editing match up, this is not very easy to fix with iMovie. If you haven’t emptied the Trash in a while, you could pull up the rest of the shot that you clipped, and add in those couple frames. However, you cannot merge the two shots into one big shot, so there will be a tiny shot in between your other ones. This makes transitions difficult. What’s easier is to take the time to reimport the entire clip and recut the shot. But remember, until you empty the Trash, all your edits are still there and ready to be used if you need them.

So...that’s all I know. I haven’t used all the options in iMovie yet, and I probably never will, since I’m a simplistic kind of person. But everything’s easy to get to, and nothing’s permanent, so playing around is not difficult at all. Have fun with it! There are times I wish for a better program, but iMovie works well and it’s free and the vids come out nicely. For a beginning vidder, that’s all you can ask for. :-)
Tags:
 
 
( 28 comments — Leave a comment )
Allison: Katee  -Capslocky!frolicndetour on December 17th, 2009 01:54 pm (UTC)
Eeeee thank you!! This is so detailed (which I need); thank you so much! I'll definitely get good use out of it. <3

*runs off to exam, but will be back this weekend*
Merry Kivanolix on December 18th, 2009 12:31 am (UTC)
Let me know if you have any questions after you read it!
Allison: Christmas Peanutsfrolicndetour on December 24th, 2009 03:25 am (UTC)
I just have to thank you again! I've hit a bit of a snag in the form of a computer crash, so I need to re-procure imovie six (the version I have now is impossible to vid with, or so I've heard), but hopefully I'll be able to at least get something started over break, and I'm keeping this bookmarked for when I do. <3
Zoe: Atlantis!caramel_monkey on December 17th, 2009 10:53 pm (UTC)
Wow, nice tut!
Hahah, yeah my timing was slightly off on the last vid I did. I reaaally wanna repost and replace it. :(
Merry Kivanolix on December 18th, 2009 12:31 am (UTC)
Thanks! I always want to fix something about my vids after they're posted.
Zoe: VMD apple.caramel_monkey on December 18th, 2009 12:39 am (UTC)
It's totally annoying! :P
And then knowing you *can't* fix it since you wanna keep all your views + comments.
Becka: we are the cylon vidding machine!beccatoria on December 18th, 2009 08:09 pm (UTC)
Interesting! Even though I don't own a Mac and will likely never own a Mac, this was interesting reading.

I have to say, while I do not for a second doubt that Macs are better in almost every way for video editing, etc., I think that trying to use iMovie would drive me insane! While it sounds like it has vastly superior functionality to WMM (for instance, you can't reverse clips in WMM, you have to do it in another program and then reimport; very frustrating!), the import process sounds bananas! In WMM (indeed in every other vidding program I've used) the video files aren't recreated for the video editor - it just non-destructively uses the video files you designate as source files and pulls the footage directly from them, by making markers about where the clip in your timeline starts and stops in the source video file, so importing usually takes less than a minute (though WMM can crash while doing so because, well, WMM will crash when you sneeze in the room next to your computer...)

Then again some of this is also down to my inexplicable fear of clipping! CLIPPING! I hate it! Why should I clip? FEH. I shall use entire episodes because I'm lazy, dammit! Ahem.

Seriously, though, as I've continued as a vidder I more and more often start vids without a clear idea of exactly what I'm going to use and feel my way through more - after my fourth or fifth vid I stopped using formal storyboards most of the time. I'm not sure whether that's helped me or not, but...well, it's interesting, and makes me wonder how our video editors affect our development as vidders?

For instance if I'd been working in this sort of environment, I probably would have had storyboards a lot more ingrained into my process; similarly, when I finally moved away from WMM to other editors which gave me multiple video tracks it took a while for me to really understand what that gave me and to do more work with overlays, etc.

WMM also made me an incredibly linear video editor. Even now that I have other options, I hate the thought of starting to vid the chorus, or the musical bridge, and then going back to the start later or to fill in other bits later makes me all....eeeew *shudder* I like to start at the start and end at the end and try and be as exact as I can the whole way through. But I know that one of my friends really doesn't worry about exact timing until she has a rough draft of all the clips she wants and THEN goes back and makes sure everyone's moving to the beat, and the clips synch up, etc.

And at this point, I'm really not talking about your tutorial anymore *facepalm* But hey! I HAD THOUGHTS! :)
Merry K: river bibleivanolix on December 19th, 2009 12:29 am (UTC)
Oh most definitely! I'm trying to work out how I can get a Windows computer so I can use WMM (do you have to purchase it, btw, or does it come with the computer like iMovie?), because iMovie was not designed for vidding. Its original purpose was specifically for film from digital cameras, to be edited and then burned to a DVD. For that process, all its quirks make sense. For anything else, it's just a free application that will let you make basic vids if you know how to work around things.

That being said, it does fit with my personality (mostly). I outline just about every fic I write, and I don't think that would have been different with vidding even if it didn't take so much work to clip/import. Likewise, I always start with the beginning on everything. I can do non-linear on-the-fly, but it's stressful, so I probably wouldn't have taken to vidding if I couldn't be organized about it. ;-)
Becka: crossbonesbeccatoria on December 19th, 2009 01:13 pm (UTC)
Nah, WMM is free. It comes with every OS since XP, although the XP and Vista versions are slightly different. They can still open each other's save files (I think) but if you want custom effects (there are a bunch of places on the net where you can get them), then you need to make sure you get the Vista or XP-specific ones.

But yeah, it's free and if for any reason it's not on your OS, you can download it for free from the Microsoft site, I think.

The only other semi-serious suggestion I'd have about getting hold of easier-to-use free and legal video editing software would be to dual boot your Mac with a linux distribution, though I know that risks me sounding like a crazy linux-preaching fangirl (which...I kind of am, but also not because it really isn't for everyone). If you had Windows, you could add Ubuntu to your system without even partitioning your drive or anything scary - they have a 1.5meg program you run that sets it all up for you in a fake virtual partition and is uninstallable like any other program. Just...this "program" is another operating system you enter. And from there you'd have access to a number of video editing programs of varying complexity and ease of use.

But I think installing it on a Mac is slightly trickier and I don't really know anything about that, sorry. Though a lot of linux OSes do offer Live CDs which is basically when the entire OS will run from a CD so you can try it out without changing anything on your computer. Some of those probably come with video editing software on the CD (rather than having to install it later which you wouldn't be able to do if you were just using a Live CD). It'd be a bit slower than running it installed on your Mac, but it might be a way of testing it out if you really wanted to have a look.

I mean, ultimately that's probably going to be a hell of a lot more complicated than you want just to get a slightly less hassle ridden vidding program (replacing one kind of hassle with another!) and it'd be easier to get a Windows computer if you can borrow one or afford it. But...be warned, WMM crashes like a BITCH and vidding in it is somewhat like getting into a knife fight. ;) I mean, obviously it works, or I wouldn't have stuck with it for years but...it was an antagonistic love/hate relationship.

Thanks for the information on iMovie; it actually does make it make a bit more sense now. Is there really no free video editing software that comes with a Mac? That's a real shame, since they have such great software if you're willing to pay.

I'm like you, though. I'm...not non-linear. When I'm writing too, even if I don't know quite where I'm going, I still have to tell the story straight through and find my way there, I can't just jump ahead to a scene I think is cool then fill the blanks in later.
Merry Kivanolix on December 19th, 2009 03:45 pm (UTC)
On first thought, the idea of Linux sounds absolutely wonderful...on second thought, I'm a computer luddite, and though I have two friends who aren't, it would be stressful. But so would continual crashing, so maybe I'll be ready to switch soon. I'm sure there's no lack of information on Mac/Linux OSs, although I might end up asking you about vidding programs, since I doubt that is most people's first reason for switching. ;-)
Becka: crossbonesbeccatoria on December 19th, 2009 09:34 pm (UTC)
Well I'd be happy to help you with Cinelerra which is what I'm using, but fair warning, while it doesn't crash for me and has SO MUCH more functionality, it is kind of complicated from what I was using with WMM. It was somewhat easier for me to make the jump via an intermediate somewhat more complex program. Also I did also find a few tutorials that helped me and could point you in the direction of those as well as telling you a few things I found useful at the time.

As to linux itself, I use Ubuntu - the tagline is "linux for humans" and it's...kind of living up to its name, actually. I'm not a complete luddite, but I am fairly untechnical when it comes to anything about how the computer actually works rather than a GUI (graphical user interface - i.e. the pretty "press a button" route of doing things rather than entering code in a command line).

The most terrifying part of ubuntu is partitioning your harddrive so that you can have two systems on your computer (you then end up choosing at start up which you want to go into), but there is a fairly easy-to-use wizard that helps you with that, so it's mostly just theoretically terrifying and it gives you automatic suggestions and stuff, so you're highly unlikely to accidentally uninstall your Mac OS.

Once you have Ubuntu it's pretty easy and obvious how to use it. Most programs are accessed through an "app store" type place called the "software centre" which is very logically placed under "applications". From there you can install basically everything you're ever likely to need including four or five simple video editing programs, though not cinelerra, and I couldn't give you much help with those (though when I've played round with them they're pretty simple).

But I will warn you that sometimes fixing stuff requires pasting code into a command line. It's not usually hard because usually it really is just a copy-paste job, but...some people find that intimidating and I get why.

So yeah, basically, it's...not actually any harder for a luddite, I don't think, than any other operating system objectively. But if you already have experience in one system or another, it will be stressful because it's new.

For instance, the software centre I mentioned? It searches whatever "repositories" you've added to your "package manager" (so for instance, cinelerra isn't included, so you'd need to add the cinelerra "repository" to the "package manager").

The benefit of doing it this way is that when you add "repositories" to your "package manager", your system automatically keeps your software up to date with new updates, etc., and you can search in one central app store for new stuff rather than going specifically to the websites for either the installation files or to check for updates (or having to check in the program). So logically, that's easier. But it's also a huge mental leap sideways from what I'm used to in Windows and takes some getting used to thinking about it that way.

So, I don't mention this cus I think you're gonna leap at the chance to switch tomorrow but just...stuff to know for the future, maybe. And if you do ever try it and want help from a fellow Linux Luddite, I'd be more than happy to help. Certainly I could give you easy step-by-step instructions on how to make sure you have the restricted media packages installed (so that you can play DVDs and divx-encoded avi files, and use YouTube) and how to add Cinelerra to your computer, etc. if you needed.
Beckabeccatoria on December 19th, 2009 09:44 pm (UTC)
Err, forgot to mention - and I apologise if you already knew this - but once you've installed Ubuntu, it should run identically to any other installation regardless of if it's on a Mac or PC, I'm pretty sure... It's just the installation process that might be different, for instance, I know that Super Easy Installer that they made only works in Windows because it's not really installing a new OS.
Annieaducale10 on December 19th, 2009 03:02 am (UTC)
You seriously read my mind... I've been contemplating putting together a video. Right now I'm feeling Torchwood but I'm trying to get inspired to do a Sam/Kara one. Argghhh... If only work would give me time.
Merry K: kara sam tattoosivanolix on December 19th, 2009 04:37 am (UTC)
Ooh, awesome—I hope you get to do one. :-) I have something like 50 vid ideas right now...it's insane, I'll never have enough time to do them all.
blitzed451blitzed451 on December 21st, 2009 01:45 am (UTC)
I've always owned Macs so when I started vidding (in 1996), I naturally looked at the iMovie option but there were two issues which made me look elsewhere. The first you've already mentioned, and that was that beginning with iMovie 6 the program actually copied every vid file imported into your project, rather than merely referring to the file where it exists on the hard drive. This is fine for home movie editing, but not for a fan vidder who wants to use footage from the same show in different vids, or who just wants to have a whole mess of clips in the project so you can try and err as often as you want. I just don't have the discipline to know that far in advance exactly what my vid is going to require.

The other issue I had with iMovie - and I don't know if that's been corrected but I suspect not - is that you couldn't mix 4:3 footage with 16:9 - and since I started out vidding Farscape there was just no way I could consider iMovie.

I ended up buying Final Cut Express, which lets you import vid files as "reference files" and not as actual duplicates, has a decent amount of preset effects and transitions which you can adjust, lets you mix aspect ratios easily, and allows multiple video tracks (great for overlays) - to name a few of its virtues. It also comes packaged with LiveType - a titling program which also features a lot of beautiful backgrounds which can be customized and then imported into your FCE project. I think FCE gives you a lot for your money, and though I upgraded a few years ago to the Pro version, there isn't a whole lot of difference between the two programs, for fan vidding purposes anyway.

Not to ignore your tutorial....which is very comprehensive. Good for you that you're able to make it do your vidding! But....is it free now? It used to be free in days of yore (when Apple was the "friendly" computer company) but I had to buy it as part of iLife'06.

Also - I think its very sage advice to let a new vid "sit" before posting it. It's amazing how often something you thought was a great idea one day, strikes you as total rubbish the next. Thanks for the tute! :-)
Merry K: aeryn sunivanolix on December 21st, 2009 04:41 am (UTC)
Actually, I never had a problem with the footage ratio mixing. In fact, there were a couple times when it mixed a little too well, and I had to find a way to make it all appear more uniform.

And yes, iMovie is free, which is the only reason I'm still using it. I'm a bit of a cheapskate when it comes to things I only use for fannish endeavors, but my perfectionist nature is starting to be very unsatisfied with the merely "good enough" nature of iMovie.

(And Farscape, yay!)
JoJo: Ezra tips hatsolosundance on December 21st, 2009 12:02 pm (UTC)
Thanks for this, it's fabulous. Just shows me how much more I have to learn though *g* Still, if you don't at first succeed ... :-)
Merry Kivanolix on December 21st, 2009 03:26 pm (UTC)
You're welcome! :-)
T.M.: Apple/Macshfan on December 21st, 2009 06:36 pm (UTC)
I've been vidding with iMovie since 2007. I recently purchased Final Cut Express, and although I figured out enough to produce my first vid on it using key frames to zoom and pan, I much prefer my little iMovie program. I have bought a lot of plug-ins and I know iMovie so well, it's easy to manipulate what I want.

I love iMovie 6 HD. I really wished Apple would have built upon this dinosaur. iMovie 8 is compatible with FCE and 6HD isn't.
Merry Kivanolix on December 21st, 2009 11:30 pm (UTC)
Ooh, I didn't realize you could buy plug-ins. Are those for iMovie6 or later versions? That might be worth it, assuming I don't just eventually buy Final Cut.
T.M.: Vidding Seatsshfan on December 21st, 2009 11:40 pm (UTC)
http://www.geethree.com/slick/index.html

I've found GeeThree to be the best, but expensive. Very easy to download, and of course you can see samples of what you're buying. And yes, it's compatible with iMovie 6.

Yes, iMovie 6 has it's limits, but I feel a lot more limited on FCE. I'm too used to iMovie and I'm not finding FCE as user friendly.
Merry Kivanolix on December 22nd, 2009 12:27 am (UTC)
Thank you for that link! That may actually be worth the price, given that I really like iMovie's format, I'm just finding it limited.
sweeney32sweeney32 on January 12th, 2010 03:33 am (UTC)
What a wonderful tutorial and so full of information! I need to go back over your artistic section of the tutorial, because I know there many nuggets of wisdom there.

But I have to say . . . No no no, by all that is holy, do NOT, DO NOT try to transition over to WMM! That is totally going down in the world! iMovie 6 or iMovie 9 are both great for vidding, they just have their own way of getting things done. They both are so much better than WMM.

And also, your Mac should have come with some version of iMovie installed, at no extra cost to you. My latest Mac Mini had iLife 09 with iMovie 09, and I make a lot of fanvids with it. iMovie 08 is not so good, but if you have iMovie 08 you're entitled to iMovie 6, which is a good vidding app, so either way, as long as you have a fairly recent Mac, you *should* have a copy of iMovie at no extra cost.

I agree that waiting for iMovie 6 is miserable when you have to wait for everything to convert to DV, but I think Apple's motivation there was that they were going to make sure you used an editable codec, which could be edited frame-by-frame. That's also why DV has such large file sizes—because all codecs that are editable (easy to edit frame-by-frame) are larger. Compressed codecs like WMV, H.264, DivX or XviD AVI, they can crash your software if you try to edit them directly. This is probably why some people report WMM crashing—they're trying to edit some compressed video files. So iMovie simply doesn't give you that option.

Also, have you tried out iMovie 6's timing markers yet? They are not really meant for marking music videos (only one marker per second) but they can really help. And iMovie 09 has bonafide beat markers which make it perfect for fanvids. The way to set a marker in iMovie 6 is to press Shift+Apple and then M. What I do is have my fingers over both Shift and Apple, then start to play the music and tap M to follow the beat. This works pretty well. But like I said, only one marker per second, so if you have a fast-paced video you'll have to improvise.

I host a site with a bunch of fanvids and we have some iMovie users and they can have gorgeous, almost DVD-quality in their videos. There are some tricks they use to do that which I can tell you about, but this post is too long already! LOL.

And another thing I love about iMovie (both 6 and 09) is that HD looks great. Both these apps can edit true HD video.

I hope you don't mind me being shameless (but I AM shameless) for linking to some of the videos made in iMovie, but I want to show what it can do. Here's All The Above by Jaime: http://www.rafanvids.com/General-RA-vids/All-The-Above-Richard-DivX-HD-ff.avi (Just right click to download). Made in iMovie 06.

Visitation by Damaris: http://www.rafanvids.com/General-RA-vids/Visitation-wm-proj-H.264.mp4 (Damaris is known for getting gorgeous quality. She also uses the Slix plug-ins.)

Throw it on Me by BBE: http://www.rafanvids.com/Spooks-S7/Throw-it-on-Me-Lucas-North.avi The watermark and border were added in Final Cut, but all the editing was done in iMovie 09. Note that you can pan-zoom in any direction. You are given complete control on how to do that.

Magic and Ecstacy edited by me in iMovie 6: http://www.rafanvids.com/Robin-Hood-S3/Magic-and-Ecstasy-DivX-HD.avi It's pretty much rubbish, I did it just to demo HD, but as you can see, iMovie is great with HD.

Feeling Good (also by me) made in iMovie 09: http://www.rafanvids.com/General-RA-vids/Feeling-Good-Lambert-RA-H.264%20proj.mp4 It has some fast-paced bits which were possible due to the markers and iMovie 09's advanced features.

Stick with iMovie 6 (which is great) or get iMovie 09 (I think you can get it for maybe $50 or so on eBay) because either of them are TONS better than WMM. WMM has no markers and it doesn't allow you to pan-zoom with control and the quality in iMovie (both versions) can be quite good.

I've got a few tutorials on some of this stuff, but I've rambled on long enough as it is. Just let me know if you're interested and I can send you links. It sounds like you are doing very well already, though! Bravo!
Merry K: nerdyivanolix on January 12th, 2010 04:14 am (UTC)
Wow, great comment! And yes, iMovie came free, but I couldn't make sense out of iMovie 8 at all.

I'd love to hear your other thoughts/see your tutorials.

doesn't allow you to pan-zoom with control

Is this in iMovie 9? Because I'm pretty sure it's not an option in iMovie 6
sweeney32sweeney32 on January 12th, 2010 04:52 am (UTC)
Pan-zoom is in iMovie 09, and I love it. I think there might be a plug-in (not sure how much it costs if anything) to do the same thing in iMovie 6.

As for tutorials, I'm a verbose geek, so here goes! LOL!

Editing in iMovie 6 with HD: http://www.elvirasweeney.com/iweb/ElviraSweeney/iMovie_6_HD_tutorial.html

There's a whole bit there for timing markers and editing to the beat. Also info on how to export out. The tutorial is for HD but I do give info on editing standard definition. (Though come to think of it, I think sometimes iMovie 6 has trouble with quality if you export with anything other than "Full Quality." Or maybe that's a bug that Apple has finally fixed. In any case, Full Quality is pretty good.)

iMovie 6 tutorial. It's getting pretty long in the tooth and I need to update it! LOL: http://www.foolishpassion.org/mac-vidding/vidding-tutorial-1.html

This page has links at the bottom for other tutorials, some which are on a vidding forum (free membership to view): http://www.foolishpassion.org/mac-vidding/vidding-tutorial-1-page4.html

And if you friend me, I have some additional tutorials for Mac (and PC) on my LJ blog here. Some of them are getting a bit long in the tooth as well, alas.

I also just wrote a tutorial for "Mac Vidding on the Cheap" for people who want to switch to a Mac cheaply by getting an old used G4 and an old copy of Final Cut Express. Since you already have your Mac this doesn't really apply to you, but the info about Final Cut Express might be helpful later on: http://oldmac.elvirasweeney.com/final-cut-tutorial.html It shows some of the features in Final Cut Express, which I think is a fantastic application and so cheap for all that it gives you. Its Windows counterparts (Sony Vegas Movie Studio, Premiere Elements—which are both great apps, don't get me wrong) but they don't have near as many advanced features as Final Cut Express.

Hope this helps and again, you've written a great tutorial!
tardis_stowaway: big damn herotardis_stowaway on February 6th, 2010 04:23 am (UTC)
Ooh! I want to try my hand at vidding, and I'm currently in the information-gathering and preparation stage. This is just the sort of tutorial I've been looking for! The clarity of the writing is great. This tutorial is going in my memories.
Merry K: samivanolix on February 6th, 2010 02:12 pm (UTC)
I'm glad you found it useful!
Franzifranzeska on September 12th, 2010 10:34 pm (UTC)
This is so helpful! I'm a n00b using imovie, and I've been scratching my head over various things.

One thing I've found very helpful is the "Revert Clip to Original" feature (for when I've trimmed off a couple of frames too many).
( 28 comments — Leave a comment )